• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

FBI Studies

  • Home
  • Ray Batvinis
    • Speaking
    • Research
  • Blog
    • Videos
  • Hoover’s Secret War against Axis Spies
    • Praise
    • Chapter 1
    • Book Reviews
    • Book Lecture Video
  • Origins of FBI Counterintelligence
    • Praise
    • Book Review
    • Introduction
    • Chapter One
    • CSPAN Video
  • Resources
    • Videos
    • History News
    • Store
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Blog / Looking back at a previous refugee crisis

November 21, 2015 By Raymond J. Batvinis, PhD

Looking back at a previous refugee crisis

stlouisref

I was interviewed by Glenn Garvin of the Miami Herald who wrote an article about a previous time the US refused to let refugees in:

1939 ‘Voyage of the Damned’ raises questions about treatment of Syrian refugees (Miami Herald)

It would become known, with heartbreak and infamy, as the Voyage of the Damned. Seventy-six years ago, an ocean liner carrying more than 900 Jewish refugees fleeing Adolf Hitler’s Germany hovered aimlessly for 72 hours just a couple of miles off the Florida coast while Jewish leaders in Washington frantically begged President Franklin D. Roosevelt to let the passengers into the United States. “So near, and yet so far,” one passenger murmured to her husband as they watched traffic darting about Miami Beach.

Farther than she even guessed. Roosevelt said no, and the SS St. Louis sailed back to Europe, where World War II was just weeks away. Many of the passengers would fall back into the hands of the Nazis they were trying to escape. About 250 of them did not survive the war.

The decision to turn away the St. Louis was a grotesquely ugly moment in American history, one for which Congress and the U.S. State Department would eventually apologize. Now the governors of 26 states are urging President Barack Obama to turn away another group of refugees, 10,000 people fleeing the civil war in Syria. So: Is this another St. Louis moment? . . .

And my part:

. . . . Eizenstat, who has closely studied the U.S. government’s handling of the St. Louis, understands the concern about terrorists posing as refugees. He nonetheless thinks the problem can be overcome, citing two much bigger influxes of refugees from hostile regions: the hundreds of thousands of Vietnamese who came to the United States after the communist victory in South Vietnam in 1975, and the more than 100,000 Cubans who came during the 1980 Mariel boatlift.

“In both those cases, we set up screening centers and we weeded out the people who might have been spies or government agents,” he said. “In the case of the Vietnamese, in particular, the North Vietnamese and Viet Cong were serious, hard-core — well, we didn’t use the word terrorists, but that’s what they were. But we kept them out. We can do that with the Syrians, too. I have confidence in the FBI and CIA and Homeland Security.”

“We worried about it, because we were paid to worry about it,” says Raymond Batvinis, a former FBI agent who participated in the Mariel screening, who now teaches at George Washington University and has written two books on the bureau’s counterintelligence operations. “There were some people about whom we for sure had suspicions. But in the end, at least to my knowledge, we never found anyone who was a Castro spy.”

However, Batvinis thinks that worries about spies or terrorists disguised as refugees are quite sensible. And if there weren’t any spies among the St. Louis passengers, he adds, it probably wasn’t for lack of the Nazis trying. “They certainly used refugees to spy in the United States,” he says. At least four German refugees — two of them Jewish — surrendered to the FBI as soon as they arrived, confessing that they had been coerced into working for the Nazis. A fifth, who didn’t turn himself in, was caught, convicted and sent to prison.

The possibility of terrorist sleeper agents is not the only difference St. Louis survivors see between themselves and the Syrians. While Germany was changing rapidly under Hitler, they say, refugees fleeing the country were fundamentally products of western democracy. The Syrians are not, and they don’t want to play by the rules of western liberalism, but change them. . . .(read the whole article)

Share this:

  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Blog, History News

Primary Sidebar

Follow Ray

Facebooktwitterlinkedinrssyoutube

Books by Dr. Ray Batvinis

Origins of FBI Counterintelligence

Hoovers Secret War Against Axis Spies book cover

Recent Posts

  • CODENAME: WALLFLOWER — The Guy Liddell Diaries
  • Message from FBI Director Wray re Bob Levinson
  • COVID 19 Message from the FBI
  • A Morning to Remember
  • The First Victory
  • The spies among us: More Chinese agents digging up secrets in Florida
  • IG Report and Message from Director Wray
  • Arne Treholt Espionage Case
  • Facts and the new “Wall of Spies” re Koval and Weisband
  • Senate Caucus Room
  • American Citizen Arrested for Acting as an Illegal Foreign Agent of the People’s Republic of China
  • North American Society for Intelligence History 2019 Conference
  • What Was He Thinking?
  • The FBI’s Role in D-Day
  • VENONA: The Opening Moments

Watch Videos

videopixCheck out all the videos on FBI Studies related to FBI history and espionage. Video Page

FBI Studies Tweets

My Tweets

Footer

About

Historical FBI Studies by Raymond J. Batvinis, PhD, author of "The Origins of FBI Counterintelligence" and "Hoover's Secret War Against Axis Spies: FBI Counterintelligence During World War II." About Ray Batvinis

Contact Ray

Contact Form
Facebooktwitterlinkedinrssyoutube

Watch Videos

videopixCheck out all the videos on FBI Studies related to FBI history and espionage. Video Page

Recent Posts

  • CODENAME: WALLFLOWER — The Guy Liddell Diaries
  • Message from FBI Director Wray re Bob Levinson
  • COVID 19 Message from the FBI
  • A Morning to Remember
  • The First Victory
  • The spies among us: More Chinese agents digging up secrets in Florida
  • IG Report and Message from Director Wray
  • Arne Treholt Espionage Case
  • Facts and the new “Wall of Spies” re Koval and Weisband

Copyright 2020 Raymond J. Batvinis, PhD | Website by CJKCREATIVE.COM