• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

FBI Studies

  • Home
  • Ray Batvinis
    • Speaking
    • Research
  • Agent Link
    • Praise
    • Chapter One
    • Book interviews
  • Hoover’s Secret War
    • Praise
    • Chapter 1
    • Book Reviews
    • Book Lecture Video
  • Origins of FBI CI
    • Praise
    • Book Review
    • Introduction
    • Chapter One
    • CSPAN Video
  • Blog
    • Videos
  • Resources
    • Videos
    • History News
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Blog / Multiple government agencies investigating employees identified in ‘Deep State’ video

September 20, 2018 By Raymond J. Batvinis, PhD

Multiple government agencies investigating employees identified in ‘Deep State’ video

I was interviewed for another article in Circa:

The Justice Department, Department of State and Government Accountability Office are looking into three employees affiliated with the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) after they were featured in a secretly recorded sting video. The video purports to show the employees may have committed ethics violations or used government resources to engage in political activities. . . .

. . . . O’Keefe sent his colleagues to expose a handful of government employees who are involved with the Democratic Socialists of America. An auditor at the Government Accountability Office (GAO), a State Department agency analyst and a former chief of staff at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid each discussed efforts to “resist” Trump administration policies from within executive agencies. Three of those employees are now under review, according to statements from GAO and the Justice and State Departments. . . .

. . . . O’Keefe claims the undercover recordings provide evidence of a “cabal of federal employees” acting to undermine President Donald Trump’s agenda and violate federal laws. “It shows other people resisting, gloating about how they can’t get fired, talking about the laws that they’re breaking. They’re quite brazen about it, quite arrogant.”

Dr. Raymond Batvinis is a former FBI counterintelligence official who spent 25 years working in the federal government. He said he does not believe the type of conspiracy O’Keefe claims to expose exists, in part, because it is not feasible.

“As a purely practical matter, I just don’t see how it could happen, particularly at the mid-level of government employees,” Batvinis noted.

The federal government employs more than 2 million full-time workers across the country and across agencies. Each agency has its own culture and is led by political appointees.”There’s no one individual or tiny cabal or clique of people who are manipulating these things,” Batvinis stressed. . . .

. . . . In one video, an auditor with the Government Accountability Office, Natarajan Subramanian, admitted to undermining work at the agency and “slow-balling” it “to the degree that it’s ineffective.”

Subramanian, a member of DSA, also suggested he worked to advance DSA’s political agenda while he was on the clock and intentionally misrepresented his involvement in the organization on a government disclosure form.

On Thursday, the GAO announced it was investigating the issues raised in the video and had communicated with the GAO Inspector General.

GAO’s public affairs director, Chuck Young issued a statement that Subramanian “has been removed from any ongoing GAO work and cut off from access to GAO equipment.” He said the agency “will also examine his work product as part of our investigation.”

In another video, Allison Hrabar, a paralegal in the Justice Department’s antitrust division, was recorded discussing her involvement with the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), including how she obtained the home addresses of a Washington lobbyist the group wanted to protest. . . . .

. . . . In one video, Hrabar explains to an undercover Project Veritas reporter that she found Wilely’s home by running his license plates. “We cannot do it officially,” Hrabar said. In a separate clip, she said she used”public information and research” to find the address.

Another DSA member said Hrabar relied on software, like Lexis Nexis, an expensive subscriber database often used by universities, researchers and the government. The video implied Hrabar may have used her government account to find Wilely. That would likely violate the Hatch Act, a law prohibiting the use of government time or resources to engage in political activity.

“What’s kind of lucky is at the DOJ, we can’t really get fired,” Hrabar told a Project Veritas reporter.

A Justice Department spokesperson called the allegations “deeply concerning.” Justice Department policy “prohibits misuse of government resources to advance personal interests. We are looking into this immediately and have referred this matter to the Inspector General as well,” the spokesperson said.

Another video featured Stuart Karaffa, a State Department analyst with the Bureau of Overseas Buildings Operations and according to Project Veritas, a “ranking member” of the Metro DC Democratic Socialists of America.

Karaffa admits to drafting emails for DSA while he is at work. He acknowledged he could get in trouble if caught, but told the undercover reporter, “I have nothing to lose. It’s impossible to fire federal employees.” . . .

. . .  According to a recent poll, roughly 73 percent of Americans believe there is a “deep state,” described as a group of unelected government and military officials who secret manipulate or direct national policy. Only 5 percent are confident such a structure definitely does not exist.

The longterm effects on society of promoting this belief are worrisome, Batvinis said. “All it does is weaken confidence and the trust the American people have in the government,” he warned. “There’s this constant drumbeat. People begin to believe it. And I believe it’s not healthy for our government, it’s not healthy for our democracy.” (read entire article)

Share this:

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

Related

Filed Under: Blog

Primary Sidebar

Books by Dr. Ray Batvinis

Origins of FBI Counterintelligence

Hoovers Secret War Against Axis Spies book cover

Recent Posts

  • “Agent Link” Book Event at the International Spy Museum
  • The Forgotten Soviet Spy: AGENT LINK
  • Spy Valley: An Engineer’s Nuclear Betrayal
  • Radio Cloak and Dagger
  • A Response To The Fourth Man by Robert Baer – By Richard Rita
  • The Ghost of Angleton – By Paul Redmond
  • Sometimes the story is about the spies who aren’t there
  • Former CIA Counterintelligence Chiefs Weigh in on The Fourth Man
  • The Charles McGonigal Case
  • The Ghost of Angleton — Review of The Fourth Man
  • Spycraft 101 Podcast Interview
  • Message from Director Wray Regarding Search at Mar-a-Lago, Florida
  • World War II House of Secrets
  • Walking a Tightrope: FBI’s John Cimperman and the ULTRA Secret
  • Watergate: Competing Fond Memories

Watch Videos

videopixCheck out all the videos on FBI Studies related to FBI history and espionage. Video Page

Most Viewed Posts

  • The Ghost of Angleton - By Paul Redmond
  • The Manhunt and Capture of Vincent Loonsfoot in the North Woods of Michigan
  • Was Roger Hollis a British patriot or Soviet spy?
  • Words of Wisdom from Sherlock Holmes
  • The FBI’s Fake Russian Agent
  • The Paul Rico Case
  • Sherlock Holmes Joke
  • Review of book in Michigan War Studies Review
  • The First Victory
  • A Response To The Fourth Man by Robert Baer - By Richard Rita

Footer

About

Historical FBI Studies by Raymond J. Batvinis, PhD, author of "The Origins of FBI Counterintelligence" and "Hoover's Secret War Against Axis Spies: FBI Counterintelligence During World War II."

 

A retired FBI Supervisory Special Agent, Ray is now a historian and educator specializing in the discipline of counterintelligence as a function of statecraft.

Copyright 2024 Raymond J. Batvinis, PhD | Website by CJKCREATIVE.COM

 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.